Validation of the Comprehensive ICF Core Sets from the Patient Perspective

Michaela Coenen (Munich, Germany)


One essential key aspect within the process of the validation of ICF Core Sets is the patient perspective. While the patient perspective has been included implicitly in the ICF (e.g. limitations of activities, restriction of participation, personal factors), the patients are now explicitly involved in the process of the validation of ICF Core Sets. As standards of functioning and health in research and clinical practice, the ICF Core Sets should address the perspective of those who experience the disease.
Qualitative methodology provides the possibility to explore the perspective of those who experience a health problem, i.e. the so called patient perspective. To validate the ICF Core Sets two of the most broadly used methods in qualitative research - focus groups and individual interviews - are used. The objectives of patient focus groups or individual interviews are (a) to explore and understand the perspective of individuals with a specific health condition on functioning and health using a qualitative approach and (b) to identify concepts of functioning and health important to these patients using the ICF as a reference.
The Comprehensive ICF Core Set for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) was the first undergo validation from the patient perspective using focus groups* and individual interviews. Individual interviews with 21 patients with RA were performed in Vienna (Austria) and focus groups with 49 patients were performed in Munich (Germany). Transcribed data were analyzed according to the qualitative method of 'meaning condensation' which allows identifying 'meaning units' in the transcripts. Each 'meaning unit' was then linked to the most specific ICF category according to established linking rules. Both studies are completed.

Using the validation of Comprehensive ICF Core Set for RA as a case in point a protocol was developed to validate ICF Core Sets from the patient perspective to be used for different health conditions and in different countries. In the meantime several researchers have started the process of validating ICF Core Sets for different health conditions using the protocol (see table). For the studies in foreign countries listed below the open-ended questions were translated according to a standardized translation procedure.

 

Health condition
country
validated by
status

Chronic widespread pain

 

Germany Robin Hieblinger completed; publication in process
Diabetes mellitus Germany Inge Kirchberger
Franz-Xaver Hierl
in process
Low back pain Germany
Hungary
Michaela Kirschneck
Geza Balint
Agnes Fincziczki
in process
in process

Osteoarthritis (knee)

 

Singapore Feng Xie completed & published

Rheumatoid arthritis

 

Germany
Austria
Michaela Coenen
Tanja Stamm
completed & published
completed & published
Stroke Sweden
Finland
Germany
Germany
Markku Panaalathi
Markku Panaalathi
Joachim Knörzer
Andrea Gläßel
completed
in process
completed
planned

For further information please contact Michaela Coenen

back

ICF Research Branch of WHO CC F IC (DIMDI)
Institute for Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, Ludwig-Maximilian University
Home Last update 05.01.08 Impressum